Shelf Pure

Exfoliants

Salicylic and glycolic acids, two or three nights a week, never with retinol.

An unlabeled clear bottle beside a stack of cotton pads on a marble tray, generated illustration
Only what fits you

Sort the exfoliants

Skin
Main worry
Hair
Budget

Pick your answers and the shelf shows only what fits.

Exfoliants, ranked

5 picks · ordered by the rubric
Pore exfoliant
scene
#1 · Skin · Exfoliants

Paula’s Choice Skin Perfecting 2% BHA Liquid Exfoliant

Two percent salicylic acid in a short-list, leave-on liquid, sold by the maker to unclog pores and control oil. It has a long record and a tacky finish some owners cannot stand.

Skip it if you hate a sticky finish; owners call this one tacky

$37 MSRP · 4 fl ozAmazon →
Budget AHA
scene
#2 · Skin · Exfoliants

The Ordinary Glycolic Acid 7% Exfoliating Toner

A big bottle of seven percent glycolic acid for rough texture and dullness. The maker warns it off sensitive or peeling skin, and the burning reviews suggest it means that.

Skip it if your skin is sensitive or peeling; the maker says not to use it

$13.50 MSRP · 240 mlAmazon →
Beginner pick
scene
#3 · Skin · Exfoliants

COSRX AHA/BHA Clarifying Treatment Toner

A mild AHA and BHA toner in a spray bottle, sold by the maker to beginners for daily use. Too gentle to do much for some, and it still breaks out others.

Skip it if you want a strong exfoliant; some owners see no effect on blackheads

$20 MSRP · 150 mlAmazon →
Salicylic pads
scene
#4 · Skin · Exfoliants

Stridex Maximum Strength Pads

Salicylic acid 2% on a textured pad, labeled by the maker as an acne medication and free of alcohol. The list does have fragrance, menthol and ammonium lauryl sulfate, and owners split on burn and dryness.

Skip it if your skin is dry or sensitive; owners report burning and flakes

No maker list price for this size · 55 padsAmazon →
Also good
scene
#5 · Skin · Exfoliants

Pixi Glow Tonic

The well-known glycolic toner at five percent, with aloe and witch hazel. Fragrance and dye are on the list, and the scent is what its unhappy owners mention first.

Skip it if fragrance bothers you; owners call this one overpowering

$29 MSRP · 250 mlAmazon →