Petrolatum ends chapped lips; everything else maintains them.
Pick your answers and the shelf shows only what fits.
Not a petrolatum balm: octyldodecanol and castor seed oil carry panthenol, glycerin and shea butter, preservative and fragrance free according to the maker. Owners like the relief and complain about the taste.
Skip it if you want Aquaphor ointment in a tube; this is a different formula
A scented, waxy overnight lip balm in a jar, with shea and murumuru butter. Pleasant to use, and a lot of money for what is mostly a lip balm.
Skip it if you want value; this is $24.00 MSRP for 20 g
A soft wax-and-oil stick with petrolatum sixth on the list, plus shea butter, glycerin and vitamin E. It is not plain petroleum jelly, which surprises owners who wanted the small tub.
Skip it if you want plain petroleum jelly; this is not that
A glossy, cushiony balm with shea and murumuru butter in a squeeze tube. The packaging and flavors are half the appeal; moisture lasts less long than the shine.
Skip it if you want value; $24 MSRP is a lot for a balm